I'm sorry Phi, but this round has been going on long enough (and it's still not over!). I'm not seeing much activity/vote changes. Mostly jibber-jabber at this point, so I feel like people have their minds made up. We need to move on with a lynching and overnight kill so we can get some more substantive posts.
EDIT: Seriously, I don't need 4 more pages of quacking jibber-jabber.
Nah Jimmy I'm not mad at you. I'm all about getting the game moving along. Im more upset Abra got saved.
And it makes it tougher to find the mafia now. If Roo is a townie, than the mafia can split their votes between him and myself and hide more easy. Where-as a runoff between myself and abra would force them to polarize their votes.
Post by popsicle sarah on Nov 30, 2012 11:25:46 GMT -5
Checking in from my phone while I have a minute. Just got home from work and about to hop in the car and drive my mom to Savannah. This'll be the first time we're going to my Granny's since she passed. Somber occasion I'll have my laptop so I should be able to check in some.
. . . Anyway's, I would be fine with Roo, Zen or LD added in. I noticed folks pushing for a quieter player, but they weren't doing anything about it. Phi was one of those and although it's not incredibly shady, it is more so than anything I have seen. I feel it should be Roo or LD, mainly cause this is Zen's first game and we have no idea how she plays.
Phi wants quieter players in the runoff, but didn't do anything with his vote about it.
He was worried that he can't have the lead in votes, so he can't vote for who he wanted to. He has played this game before, he knows damn well he wasn't going to get voted straight off, but he will still post like he would have been.
He he calls out quiet players, not specifically me, then says "Not sure how you can even say anything Mike D . . . " after I log on and post my opinions.
And honestly, the more he posts, the more he reminds me of myself (among other players) that get into a corner early on as mafia and keep posting aggressively, calling out players early on left and right, "how can you not see this" crap, why do yall keep stacking on me, and so on.
When I look at all this, I don't have enough to know or think 100% that he is mafia, but I do believe that he is by far the most suspicious of being so.
Post by ntellier85 on Nov 30, 2012 12:49:14 GMT -5
Of course it makes sense. I already stated that I was curious as to why you were so pro me. When I first saw you post my first thought was "oh shit wtf is he doing! this is just gonna make me look more guilty!" and then I just figured that people would realize no way would a fellow mafia member be so vocal in supporting another mafia member.
and a planning ahead lynch i dont think looks necessarily guilty. thats just who he believes is also mafia. doesnt mean the rest of the townies will follow his lead.
We won't know for sure until the end of the game. We just have to do our best to guess or trust the inspector when and if they come forward with the information they have.
Has town ever won this? This is like uber hard mode. A normal game I'm used to is something like, 1 cop, 1 doc and 5 villiagers vs 3 mafia. Players are identifed after they are lynched. Mafia may only talk durning the night. And still, mafia wins slightly higher than half the games.