Post by ☮ superbek ☮ on May 26, 2009 4:40:09 GMT -5
you people are unbelievable.
I have tried to be as objective and fair as I know possible. I have tried to give everyone a fair chance and you have all bullied against me in return.
kdogg, no I do not intend to vote for myself every round. as I said before, I voted for myself because it was unfair to anyone else for me to vote for them because it was impossible for me to have suspicions of anyone on the first day. When I have a suspicion, I intend to vote for that party.
As for my plan I initially stated, you have pointed out the flaws and for that I thank you and no, I was not presuming the mafia to be stacking votes against me. I was actually referring to fishman. At the time of my plan, fish had 4 votes against him and sadie with three herself.... where did those votes come from (and rather quickly might I add)? Honestly, I watch a lot of reality tv competitions and I was trying to come up with some fresh ideas.
Listen kdogg, I know we have had some bad mafia mojo in the past but I am gonna speak concisely and sincerely to you here... I am a townsperson. I know that anyone can say that but hopefully you can realize that I have done everything that an innovative townsperson would do in my position.
Matter of fact, if I make it through all this madness, will the inspector kindly do a background check on me? Then at least one person can validate my innocence.
And what about you fishman? I saved you from death the first round and yet you have voted against me, some thanks! If I saved you then you know I must be innocent, if I was in the mafia I simply would have voted for you and moved on. karma will bite you in the ass for that, my friend.
But do you know if sadie is innocent? has she proven herself to you in anyway? nope.
speaking of sadie, yes that is the correct use of the word martyr although I will admit it is not my intention. My goal is to help lead the townspeople to victory, unfortunately no thanks to yourself.
I have tried to start this game off with class but you all are already getting dirty. If you want me dead, then so be it... but until then I change my vote to fishingmaniac.
honestly I think you should all be concerned with those people who are sitting back not saying anything... there are a lot of board veterans in this game, nobody can use the "i dunno what's going on" or "sorry I didn't log in for three weeks" excuse. know what I mean?
Post by Fishing Maniac on May 26, 2009 5:15:39 GMT -5
Well, I'm sorry that I've upset you so much, but I'm not voting for myself. The idea that me not committing suicide makes you mad at me is highly irrational. Why would I vote myself off? Why would I knowingly want to vote any townsperson off? Sorry Bek. You talk a good game, but you're trying to get me to kill myself and in doing so you are trying to get me to knowingly kill an innocent townsperson. That's the most suspicious thing that I've seen so far this game. Mafia are the only ones who want to eliminate townspeople. I now have a legitimate reason to vote for you.
Bek, I hope having legitimate questions about a plan doesn't constitute being a bully in your book... but understand that your proposal is more questionable to those other eight of us not involved, because we have nothing on any of your three's status. I questioned it because it might detract from the Townspeoples' cause in the long run, not because I think you're up to some shenanigans. Watching you over the course of this game so far, I'm inclined to believe you're innocent. Bringing up the vote-stacking possibility was my first hint. Your proposal, despite some inherent flaws, seems to be in a fair and just spirit that further suggests to me you're innocent. I think it's a bit too planned-out and coming too early in the game to be a Mafia ruse.
So I'm leaning towards your innocence, Bek... but I've got no clue about Fishman & Sadie - or anyone else, for that matter.
If I've got to pick between Fishman & Sadie... I don't think it's concrete, but there are some indications that votes might be being stacked against Fishman. That doesn't guarantee his innocence to me, but it has me leaning in that direction.
I'm going to have to vote for Sadie here. Not because she looks the most guilty to me, but at this point she seems to me the least likely to be innocent out of the three of you.
My vote for Sadie seems to be a lost cause, so I'm going to have to change mine.
The way Bek's playing seems to me like she's a fellow innocent trying to work this out. I know all three of them could be Townspeople, but at the moment I'm most convinced of her innocence. I think it would be a shame to let her die this early, when I think she could be an asset to us innocents down the line.
My vote for Sadie seems a lost cause, so if I want my vote to be effective I have no option other than to reluctantly change my vote to Fishingmaniac.