Reddit's list is strange. I don't know if I want to call it bad, it just seems like it's composed of all sorts of people including people with bad taste. I'm pretty sure their list is 2000-2009, which would explain why MBDTF isn't listed.
It'd be cool to do a list for Inforoo. Some of my personal suggestions not to forget(all 2000-2009 that Reddit didn't list): Twin Cinema by The New Pornographers, I Am Hollywood by He Is Legend, Source Tags and Codes by ... And You Will Know Us By The Trail Of Dead, Fantastic Damage by El-P, All Hour Cymbals by Yeasayer, You're a Women I'm a Machine by DFA1979, Microcastle by Deerhunter, Pet Grief by Radio Dept., Wincing the Night Away by the Shins, and Fleet Foxes s/t.
As far as what they were spot on with: Funeral by Arcade Fire, Songs for the Deaf by QOTSA, Radiohead - Kid A, The Strokes – Is This It, Kanye - College Dropout, Modest Mouse – Good News for People Who Love Bad News, Madvillain - Madvillainy, Interpol – Turn on The Bright Lights