Post by kikosanchez on Dec 31, 2012 7:42:44 GMT -5
I'm just going to assume this is where the confusion came in:
"The problem is, and I think me and Kiko are on the same page on this one, we think we know who the inspector is. And since we both seem to think inspector is still alive, we don't really want to talk about who we think it is. Obviously. Since we don't want the inspector to get whacked. (Am I right, Kiko?)"
I can see this ("on the same page") as meaning we were both on the same trail. I just read it as we were using the same methods for analysis and voting. Not that we had the exact same conclusions. Who knows what Jimmy meant by it, but it seems clear we had different conclusions nonetheless.
I actually think you & I have more similar conclusions about this than you & Jimmy do. I just don't know where he gets EAP. You'd imagine it'd be someone else... like the players you & I are voting for.
Post by superfurryanimal on Jan 1, 2013 3:21:52 GMT -5
Yeah, just like Christmas. This is extended until the same time frame, which I already talked about when the game begin. Holiday rules. Sorry I didn't make that clearer. I was distracted by someone......
But New Years isn't Christmas to me. So it's extended until tomorrow midnight roo time. Everyone check in so I know if you are around or not.
Post by abrakapokus on Jan 1, 2013 12:56:55 GMT -5
I really don't see how people are getting Bek other than the LLL thing. I've reread the posts and it seems to me that Eap is the most suspicious. I don't know if her lack of involvement or blind picking/explanation of who/why she's voting which way which makes me think that. I'm not finding a clear voting trio so maybe Mike D was mafia and we just need to hook 2 players together with voting patterns.
Re-read the thread. I feel pretty strongly that Mafia is EAP, KDogg, and a third. Maybe that third was Mike D or maybe the third is still alive.
I'll change my vote if it makes you feel any better about me. I just don't see how you come to the conclusion an Inspector has EAP's name aside from a possible false claim. Even if I did vote EAP to tie things up, we'd be leaving the ultimate decision in the hands of Bacon... and I'm not so sure about that either.
jimmy, once again, i'm not exactly sure why you have such a hard on for me and think i'm mafia. i have not done anything more suspicious than anyone else IMO. we haven't played many games together, but i usually don't post a lot unless i am having a rage out, which i am trying to be nice and avoid.
i explained both of my votes, i'm not exactly sure what else you want from me.
Post by ☮ superbek ☮ on Jan 1, 2013 17:23:51 GMT -5
Townspeople, my only advice to you is look at the votes.the fact that we're not headed into a two way run off shows that we have stacking going on. I don't get it, i mean..... Who am I working with again?
Look, if yore voting for me and you're not mafia, please reconsider before its too late.
Yeah, not knowing Bacon's whereabouts made me worried. He's on an MMJ New Year's jaunt, isn't he?
I feel we Townspeople were denied a narrower runoff last round, too. Not sure how I feel about that two votes in a row. If we're going to make it one or the other, we might as well know where every one of us stands.
Post by superfurryanimal on Jan 2, 2013 3:38:39 GMT -5
And now that the holidays are over, I'm going to be a lot more strict on runoff dates. Let's try to keep the 36 hour rule in mind and play with that. But yes, if vote switching and/or a lot discussion is going on I will extend it.
Last Edit: Jan 2, 2013 3:39:21 GMT -5 by superfurryanimal - Back to Top
Let me walk everyone through my thoughts this round. When I started the round I voted for Bek since she was the last person LLL voted for before death. As I started reading more I started becoming a little less suspicious of Bek and my vote for kiko was more about him being the most annoying player than being particularly suspicious. I often do that, it serves as a good place holder and often will shut people up a bit.
Then the run-off came and it was obvious to me I couldn't let EAP have the final say. I fully intended to change to Bek but I wanted to test a little something. Vote for NBF and see what happens. I did and exactly that and bam suddenly Bek and Eap have a ton of votes and I'm the only one on NBF. What does it mean? Well I am more suspicious of NBF than anyone else at this point.
So who to I vote for? I have been suspicious of Bek all game but she has acted clean the whole time. EAP is normally more vocal but it is the holidays and she has been out and about. Neither has really done much to make me want to off them at this point so I have to go with the person acting most out of the ordinary.
The thing with EAP was that a possible fake Inspector would have possibly had hers out of two names. I'm not as sure of that being the case as the round progressed, including when I said she was the last who belonged here. Discrediting that, I can't lean as strongly toward her innocence as I had been.
That being said, I think Bacon has been thinking along the same lines as me. We cast some similar votes and wariness over the direction votes are stacking. I'm more suspicious of either of them than the average Townie, to be honest. So I don't mind further discussion and getting on the record.
I'm open to a Bek vote too, for the record. NBF's preemptive votes for me basically set a trap for me to put myself into a runoff when I reciprocate Bek's vote, but that's not happening now that it's a runoff.
That's why I was interested to hear from Bacon. Jimmy, or anybody else, care to persuade me why I should keep my vote for EAP?
So you're saying that EAP being later to vote than Bacon means she's the more likely Mafia vote stacker? And that she chose to follow Bacon's vote to make their switch go the same way? Also, that you have a boner for EAP?
EAP has stacked on people in the runoff in both rounds. She hasn't really answered anything asked of her. Ultra quiet and useless to the town, despite being online a lot. ... And to be frank, there are some people voting for Bek that I'm very suspicious of. There has been a push for Bek to die 2 rounds now, and I know it hasn't been from myself or other likely townies like Abra and Kiko. I'm not trying to vote with the mafia.
1. You've made me reconsider Day One stacking. Best case, it's coincidence that she's involved when I see her participating in it happening. 2. I read Bek's posts and she called her Kiko vote retaliation. If she's allegedly being stacked against, couldn't that be related? Especially considering Mike D?