The way I see it, last night's kill doesn't tell us much at all. I am starting off with Bacon. Not sure if you are still recovering from camping the rail to get your avatar made or what, but all I know is that townie Bacon isn't nearly as calm as you have been. You typically are one to play much more actively and take a lead role. We got one name from the Fawn (I have accepted that she was most likely inspector) so the other two mafia, I feel, are going to be hiding back a bit.
I have been holding back for a few reasons, first of all i haven't been around all that much and second other people having been controlling the game fairly well. I have always said the reason I step up is because no one else does. That hasn't been an issue this game. I haven't had time to re-read everything yet, but my gut is telling me we may of already got 2 mafia.
If there is a second mafia dead, from my perspective, it's gotta be Werther, all that direct calling out, but indirectly following up my questions and beating around the bush. I have been looking for someone tied to him and JHamm, haven't seen much yet. It's when I start looking at folks who totally distance themselves from them, who is basically playing opposite, that's when your name/playing style jumped in my head.
Curious where the others stand, do yall think we have one or two mafia down? Do you believe Fawn, JHamm as mafia?
Post by handgunhipster on Jul 19, 2012 15:02:53 GMT -5
I believe Fawn, mostly because she confirmed my innocence, and since I am a townsperson, that is pretty convincing for me. A fake inspector would have no reason to claim I was innocent, along with a dead person, in my opinion. I'd think if she were lying, she might have named more than one mafia. I don't know. I believe her, but don't know where to go.
The town has spoken! Innocent Werther was wandering through Bonnaroo for the first time, and stumbled upon a game called Mafia and a group called Inforoo. However, little did he know, the Mafia Gods demand a virgin sacrifice to be paid in blood. High Priestess Fawn and her acolytes have appeased their gods to the great rejoicing of the town!
And so, another mafia virgin has paid the ultimate price to be reborn through their blood in the afterlife of the next game....
Mafia, PM me your whack. Inspector, PM me your guess
I'm assuming this is just an accident but weird for the ref
Ok my gut is telling me HGH is the next mafia we need to kill. The unfortunate thing is that if HGH is mafia, unless they really did stack on their own man werther because he was doing too much damage, it is likely there is still one more out there.
HGH voted Jhamm in the very begining, but he was never in any danger. EAP helped put HGH in the run-off day 2 and kept arguing for her, then EAP winds up dead. HGH originally voted for fawn in day 3, maybe after Fawn voting Jhamm the round before the mafia was trying to kill her?
It is far from air tight but it is something. Something I am going to stick with for now.
Alright, I am pushing off for NC tomorrow around 5am and won't be back to an internet connection until I arrive in NC around 3 or 4 PM. I'm banking on Fawn being the Inspector. If Fawn was Mafia, she was in no danger at the time of being voted off when she came out as Inspector. That would leave too much chance for the actual Inspector to come out and contest Fawn's claim. That means I'm inclined to believe Fawn's claim as Inspector. Granted there is always the possibility that Fawn and HGH are both Mafia, and Fawn was the sacrifice to set up HGH's assumed innocence throughout the rest of the game. I didn't overlook that, I just think its highly unlikely. I'm banking on Fawn being Inspector, which means HGH is innocent. So I'm gonna vote for the person who voted for HGH this round.
Ok second try at this. Day three tally I would say you have two options, vote fawn or vote jhamm. Mike D and NBF voted each other. Odd.
I can't get anything to pick between them though. ideas?
I didn't see those as the only two options at the time I voted because when I voted, jhamm was already pretty clearly on his way out, so I felt like a vote for him was kind of waste, and I didn't vote for fawn because, while I wasn't necessarily accepting her claim, I wasn't just taking it on faith either.
Like I said at the time, my choice of Mike D was because I figured that if Fawn was mafia, at least one of her fellow mafia would have disagreed with her in the thread because everyone agreeing with her would have been too obvious.
Her death lends some credence to her inspector claim, but I also think that if she was mafia, she would have been sacrificed for the sake of lending credibility to the claim, so I don't have a good feeling either way.
I am going to bed shortly and don't want to have to vote when I get up in the morning, so I'm sticking with my Mike D vote mainly because I think it's possible under either scenario (Fawn inspector or not) that he could be mafia. Admittedly, there may be things I am missing, but
Good enough for me. The logic there is bad imo. Voting for someone because hey they could be guilty in either case makes no sense in my mind. I think you are trying to get me to vote for him, since he voted for me. I know the technique. As mafia you always want to vote for the people you think you can get the townies to vote for.
I am most suspicious of NBF and Duddits. The way I see it, I know HGH and I are not mafia, and I would be willing to bet Bacon is a townie - take it for whats its worth, but he doesn't make simple errors like that when he is mafia. NBF is going to vote Bacon, Duddits is gone (conveniently or not) and there are my 2 most suspicious voting together. I am just glad we will have a vote not stacked beyond all hell and a non predictable kill to go off of tomorrow.