Prepared to be shocked by at least one. Like every other game i've played, I'm convinced there are at least seven mafiosa.
what are you talking about, you ARE one of the suspicious ones who randomly stacked their vote on me after initially voting for bek
I think i was quite clear, and it was not "random". You mention 'random' again even though i gave my thoughts. ??? I dont know who's who.. and suspect the run off has townies. My vote for Bek was not sitting well with me and may come back to haunt me big time. I chose to switch to you because if you are both townies, i think bek will help us more in the long run. If she's Mafia, I've made a major mistake. It's a game. people lie.. I'm not lying. I'm a townie, and i thought you were too. Not so sure now because you do not appear to be reading/hearing folks thoughts.. Provide a tangible response and I'd be willing to listen. ??
right or wrong i 'll live (or die) with this vote.
Post by abrakapokus on Dec 30, 2011 19:19:43 GMT -5
I'm at Holl's now so I'll make this quick. I'm also thinking we have two townies in the run off. I've been over and over the posts to see who seemed suspicious and neither of you do. No one does but if I go with my gut I find Bek to be more likely mafia than Phi. My reasoning is that going over old Mafia's Phi's actions this game see consistent with last game where he wasn't mafia. I think we townies are screwing ourselves here either way we go
Post by ntellier85 on Dec 30, 2011 19:25:21 GMT -5
Well now that changes everything, I guess I could find now. Its hard because I only have little to go on with bek. I know I am a townie, bek likely is too. The ONLY reason I have to believe bek could possibly be mafia, is she immediately attacked me when I was the first one to start ANY discussion about anyone being mafia (ie the fawn post wanting to know where bek/bonzai was).
For those who are voting for me, I'd like to know the reasoning why I'm more likely mafia than her.
she immediately attacked me when I was the first one to start ANY discussion about anyone being mafia (ie the fawn post wanting to know where bek/bonzai was).
Ok. So, when I was away from the game, I was thinking about switching my vote to Phi, but this statement actually got me thinking. Why would a vet attack a newbie with a vote stack for an innocent question? If it's repeatedly said that mafia are quiet, it would make Phi assume that others are guilty. I was about to change my vote, but I'll keep it where it is.
I think we have two townies. But if not, Bek... she knows this game pretty well. Having been Mafia before with her (game 41), she's pretty good and sneaky. Phi is still learning the ropes - obviously isn't going to make the Bonnie mistake again, but still... inexperienced can sell him out much easier.
Welp, Im not sure if bek was mafia, but if she was, then the 3 votes for me that at no time had bek for a vote was:
Scrog Duddits Bek
I think thats kinds of a stretch though. Me voting for you and not changing my vote through the runoffs means nothing really. I honestly thought and still think we had three Townies in the runoff(s). I voted for you, and even after that LD nor Bek (nor you really) said or did anything to make me re-think switching my vote around.
And fawn, im not even going to bother, the vote is 7-4.
They end up NOT being voted off. Not sure what that means about that this game, but I find it interesting.
I dont know what to make of this either. Interesting that it appears that the Mafia want Phi around?? Or was it just the townies. Strange game. Last day of vacation Will have more time this week for the game if i live through the night.
Even though I voted for Bek, I only was a tad more suspicious of her than Phi. I also think it's very possible that all three were townies. Can't wait to see who gets voted off to give us more insight (and I really hope that it's not me!)
WTF!? Omar posted a whopping 3 times this game. A vote for me (because I asked for a voting partner), a post asking the runoff candidates if they had anything to say to sway Omar's runoff vote, and then a vote for Bek that he picked out of a hat.
This whack makes no sense at all. I could see the Mafia trying to figure out who the Inspector is, but seriously Omar gave no indication or even hinted that he was Inspector.
We voted off bek, who was the only one of us who had more than four or five games under her belt. The rest of us are either noobs or fairly new to the game. Since there was no real vet to whack the first night then mafia doesn't have to kill someone who is experienced at sniffing them out. I think they were aiming for the inspector by picking off one of the quietest players.
Post by abrakapokus on Jan 2, 2012 20:05:15 GMT -5
Took me a while to figure out who Omar was since he has been so quiet and I usually only look at the first 3 letters of someone's screenname. I went back and read his post and I can't see any reason why Mafia would kill him off unless it was because he was a vet as KK said or they thought he was inspector. I'm finding this game very baffling!
As for the Omar whack, I see nothing he said or did that would warrant a whack, besides Mafia trying to pin him as inspector. I think the Mafia wanted to get rid of BEK, and keep Phi around. If the run-off is between two townies and it is between one who changed their vote multiple times and plays unconditional or one who has played a few more games and is being more reasonable. I want to keep the latter around. I think we need to focus on the ones who voted for Bek and those votes changes are interesting. For now...
Obviously mafia were hoping he was inspector, that is a main goal of inspector. I think it's also a possibility that they may have aimed for someone who was quiet and didn't voice any opinions because since there isn't much to go in in the game, we can't really really learn much from Omar.